Health Heart
Medical

2. ECOLOGICAL FOOTPRINT INDICATOR

TABLE 1 – INDICATOR DESCRIPTION

Information component Pg 4 Health Summary – Indicator No 2
Subject category / domain(s) Our Communities
Indicator name (* Indicator title in health profile) *Ecological Footprint
PHO with lead responsibility WMPHO
Date of PHO dataset creation 13th Feb 2007
Indicator definition The amount of productive space required to support the resource requirements and waste production for the average person measured in global hectares per person per year
Geography England, GOR, Local Authority: Counties, County Districts, Metropolitan County Districts, Unitary Authorities, London Boroughs
Timeliness Published by Stockholm Environment Institute (SEI) and created by their Resource and Energy Analysis Programme (REAP) SEI will update data annually. They hope to publish 2003 0r 2004 data in 2008.
Rationale:What this indicator purports to measure This is an indicator of sustainability from the population perspective. It is a proxy measure based on regional household expenditure, modelled at LA level by socio-economic profile.It represents the environmental “cost” (resource use and environmental degradation) associated with people’s lifestyle choice and the goods and services they buy. If everyone in the world was to make the same lifestyle decisions as the average person in the UK we would need three planets to provide the resources required.
Rationale:Public Health Importance There is a close relationship between environmental problems and social injustices, which arises from inequity in access to environmental resources and increased exposure to environmental hazards and pollution. Comparing countries and different groups within countries, the main contributors to this environmental degradation are the relatively affluent while those who suffer are the most vulnerable groups in society.With the increasing impact of climate change, particularly in developing countries, this baseline footprint in the developed world will need to be reduced to ensure good health for future generations in all parts of the world. Creating more sustainable communities is therefore a public health priority.In general, public health and cross-sector interventions, particularly those which impact on the wider determinants of health, are likely to decrease the local footprint. For example, encouraging walking and cycling, increasing availability of locally-produced fruit and vegetables and enabling home insulation. There is evidence that healthier diets can reduce the food component of the footprint by up to 40%http://www.sei.se/editable/pages/sections/implement/scotland-diet.pdf
Rationale: Purpose behind the inclusion of the indicator The broader REAP model helps identify priority areas for action, allows for forecasting the effects of interventions and explores links between income and environmental impact. Source:http://www.wwflearning.org.uk/data/files/reap-report-no-2-83.pdf. The local authority indicator alone or disaggregated into its component parts may be used as a baseline and for tracking change resulting from targeted interventions.For more detailed suggestions of how local authorities can make use of the footprint information, an account of the experience of Scottish Las is at:http://www.scotlandsfootprint.org/pdfs/SGF_Final_Report.pdf
Rationale:Policy relevance The use of this sustainability indicator as the basis for policy and decision making at LA level is in line with the government guidance Securing the Future  (March 2007) http://www.sustainable-development.gov.uk/publications/pdf/SustainableProcurementActionPlan.pdf.A number of  UK councils have signed up to the Aalborg Commitments framework, see for example, Hampshire County Council  http://www.sd-commission.org.uk/communitiessummit/show_case_study.php/00201.html. And guidance for local government is available at http://www.sd-commission.org.uk/publications.php?id=507. The Sustainable Development Commission has published numerous reports with relevant guidance includingThe Environmental dimension of children and young people’s well beinghttp://www.sd-commission.org.uk/publications.php?id=518 and Sustainable transport and active travel http://www.sd-commission.org.uk/publications.php?id=501
Interpretation: What a high / low level of indicator value means To understand the meaning of this composite indicator, it is important to look at the breakdown analysis by following the links athttp://www.sei.se/reap/local/LocalAuthority_List.php. For example a high ecological footprint may be due to high overall spending, high spending on one category such as food, or relatively high spending on a category with a disproportionate impact, such as heating. It is important to interpret the Ecological Footprint in global terms. Globally there is estimated to be 1.8 global hectares of productive space per person. A Local Authority may be low compared to the England average but is in fact very high when considered globally.
Interpretation: Potential for error Footprints calculated using this methodology may differ from local ecological footprinting carried out using less complex, life-cycle methodologies. This is not a cause for concern. The footprints used here are likely to provide a better basis for decision making at local authority level because they take into account upstream production processes and therefore more accurately reflect the environmental impacts of consumption and the allocation of responsibility.The method used by SEI makes certain assumptions: it treats imports the same as domestic product supply in terms of monetary value and it applies uniform carbon dioxide intensity to the production of imported goods. There is a very small amount of error introduced by the assignment of all secondary products to industry-based technology. There are limitations to using the data for forecasting because coefficients (input-output) will change over time.
Confidence Intervals: Definition and purpose Not applicable

TABLE 2 – INDICATOR SPECIFICATION

Indicator definition: Variable Resource consumption and environmental impact
Indicator definition: Statistic Global hectare
Indicator definition: Gender Persons
Indicator definition: age group All ages
Indicator definition: period 2001
Indicator definition: scale Per person
Geography: geographies available for this indicator from other providers England, GOR, Local Authority: Counties, County Districts, Metropolitan County Districts, Unitary Authorities, London Boroughs from SEI  See http://www.sei.se/reap/ and http://www.wwflearning.org.uk/ecological-budget
Dimensions of inequality: subgroup analyses of this dataset available from other providers Household expenditure at regional level is modelled at local authority level by CACI ACORN socio-economic profile. Many of these analyses are available at National, regional and local authority level by contacting SEI. Available fromhttp://www.wwflearning.org.uk/ecological-budget/download-centre/ecological-budget-resources,555,AR.html
Data extraction: Source Stockholm Environmental Institute
Data extraction: source URL http://www.sei.se/reap/local/
Data extraction: date Data extracted from source as at: 2nd January 2007
Numerator: definition Not applicable. . It is a composite indicator derived from the sources detailed in the methods section. There is therefore, no actual numerator or denominator. This data which is derived from household expenditure and can be broken down into over 100 consumption activities broken down into five main categories: homes (energy), transport, food, consumables and private services.
Numerator: source Stockholm Environment Institute (SEI) and created by their Resource and Energy Analysis Programme (REAP) . It can be found at:http://www.sei.se/reap/local/
Denominator: definition Not applicable. It is a composite indicator.
Denominator: source Stockholm Environment Institute (SEI) and created by their Resource and Energy Analysis Programme (REAP) . It can be found at:http://www.sei.se/reap/local/
Data quality: Accuracy and completeness Coverage is complete. Data available for all local authority areas.The data is considered complete and accurate but relies on the completeness and accuracy of underlying data, such as datasets from ONS. There is some uncertainty associated with the allocation of about 8% of the secondary products of industry. There is complete reliance on the National Footprint Account Methodology with all its assumptions and limitations.The actual footprint data is reliable; SEI uses a standardised method of calculation.

TABLE 3 – INDICATOR TECHNICAL METHODS

Numerator: extraction SEI derived this data from Classification of Individual Consumption According to Purpose (COICOP) published by ONS (2003), existing ONS accounts and ACORN data. The ONS household expenditure data is analysed at the regional level and then modelled at local authority level using the ACORN profiles.Source:http://www.wwflearning.org.uk/data/files/reap-report-no-3-96.pdf

REAPFurther information on inputs may be found athttp://www.wwflearning.org.uk/ecological-budget/

Numerator: aggregation /allocation Not applicable
Numerator data caveats The methodology used here is very complex and links the ecological footprint with input-output analysis; specifically detailed household consumption activities and detailed breakdown of capital investment.Further information can be found athttp://www.wwflearning.org.uk/ecological-budget/
Denominator data caveats The methodology used here is very complex and links the ecological footprint with input-output analysis; specifically detailed household consumption activities and detailed breakdown of capital investment.Further information can be found athttp://www.wwflearning.org.uk/ecological-budget/
Methods used to calculate indicator value See Technical guidance: http://sites.wwflearning.co.uk/data/files/reap-report-no-2-83.pdf and http://www.sei.se/reap/national.php. Methodology paper: Thomas Wiedmann T, Minx  J,  BarrettJ and Wackernagel M. Allocating ecological footprints to final consumption categories with input–output analysis. Ecological Economics 2005; 56:28-48 abstract available athttp://www.sciencedirect.com/science. Full paper from John Barrett at SEI:mailto:jrb8@york.ac.uk
Small Populations: How Isles of Scilly and City of London populations have been dealt with Individual data is not available at a Local Authority level within the Health Profiles for Isles of Scilly or City of London. However, both were included in the calculation of their County and Region data.
Disclosure Control Not applicable
Confidence Intervals calculation method Not applicable

Posted in: Indicators